The sounds of Christmas

This Christmas memory was originally posted in 2009.

The Christmas season begins for my family when we put up our tree shortly after Thanksgiving. But it’s really not trimming the tree itself that does it – it’s that as we string the lights and hang the bulbs, we listen to the traditional Grey family holiday CDs for the first time. So it’s really the music that ushers in the season for us.

And so it was when I was a child. Mom would drag out the big “portable” record player and her short stack of Christmas records and twist the volume knob up high enough that you could hear the music in the front yard. The whole neighborhood knew Christmas had arrived!

Mom favored Christmas music in pop, standards, and jazz styles, and her record stack reflected that. One of her records, Bing Crosby’s Merry Christmas, has been part of the family tradition since it was issued in 1945. My mother’s parents bought it as an album of 78-RPM discs, one song per side. Mom had it as a vinyl Lp, and I of course have it as a CD. You can own it today, too, as it is the best-selling Christmas album of all time, even though a few years ago the knuckleheads at the record company renamed it White Christmas.

But of all of Mom’s Christmas records, I liked those by Johnny Mathis the best. Johnny really gets Christmas, from hopeless sinner to joyful child. I just can’t help but sing along! When the boys and I decorate the tree, I play Johnny Mathis first.

Johnny has recorded many Christmas albums over the years but his first two are the best. His first one, also named Merry Christmas, was released in 1958. It featured lush arrangements by Percy Faith and his orchestra. But Johnny’s 1963 Sounds of Christmas is, for me, the benchmark against which I measure all other Christmas music. Johnny moves seamlessly between bright, bouncy numbers that capture the happiness to which we all aspire during this season, and traditional songs that show the full power of his voice.

Sadly, you haven’t been able to buy this album in its entirety since the 1960s. Capitol Records reissued it in the early 1970s on one of its budget labels, deleting two songs in the process, and only that abridged collection has survived. You can buy it on CD today as Christmas with Johnny Mathis. It is better than nothing.

Yet I yearned for the two deleted songs. When I discovered many years ago that Mom still had her heavily worn 1963 pressing, I recorded it on cassette. Then a couple years ago I digitized those songs into my computer, ripped Christmas with Johnny Mathis in as well, arranged the songs in the original order, and burned my own custom Sounds of Christmas CD. I made a copy for Mom, too.

If you have wished for those missing songs, then I offer them to you here in glorious mono, with all the scratches, pops, and distortion you expect from a record that was played until it was almost worn out. First is what I consider to be the definitive version of The Little Drummer Boy.

By far the best track on the album is Have Reindeer Will Travel. As my mom says, it just isn’t Christmas without the doop-doopee-doos! You’ll know what I mean when you hear the song.


21 responses to “The sounds of Christmas”

  1. J P Cavanaugh Avatar

    How odd is it that I don’t have the Bing Crosby album? And neither did my mother. I need to rectify this.

    For whatever reason, Johnny Mathes has never made my A list. I think the reindeer song is a great example of things we love because they become so deeply embedded in warm childhood memories. The Little Drummer Boy is more my speed, and very nicely done.

    In my childhood home there were two perennials: Frank Sinatra’s A Jolly Christmas from 1957 and a record by The Philadelphia Orchestra from about 1962 called The Glorious Sounds Of Christmas. I have both of them on CD today.

    1. Jim Grey Avatar

      My mom was a giant Johnny fan and so she naturally bought his Christmas albums when they came out. They are beautifully orchestrated, by Percy Faith. They are worth owning just for that.

  2. bodegabayf2 Avatar

    My fav is Bing’s Mele Kalikimaka with The Andrew Sisters. The lyrics have been stuck in my head since childhood.

    1. Jim Grey Avatar

      Oh yes, that song captured my childhood imagination as well.

  3. Andy Umbo Avatar
    Andy Umbo

    Gotta say here, in my 30’s I really, really got into the Dean Martin Christmas stuff, he was quite a “crooner”, more so than “Frank”. The other thing, for those among you who are melancholy (which is me), Jackie Gleason is little remembered as a band leader and tune writer, but he was the tops. His “lounge style” Christmas albums are not to be missed, perfect for watching a twilight snow and having a Tom & Jerry (Wisconsin and Michigan only, I think) cocktail, and at least two can be had on CD.

    1. Jim Grey Avatar

      Yeah, I think it’s a shame that Gleason didn’t remain as well known as Sinatra or Martin or their ilk. He really was an amazing talent.

  4. Don Milne - Roadtrip-'62 Avatar

    Thanks for the Johnny Mathis tracks, Jim! Merry Christmas to you and your family.

    1. Jim Grey Avatar

      Same to you and yours, Don!

  5. Christopher Smith. Avatar
    Christopher Smith.

    I’m a Nat King Cole fan myself although Johnny is quiet enjoyable to listen to, if you have a record deck the album “Johnny Mathis Sounds of Christmas” is available on eBay

    A Merry Christmas Jim to your and your Family.

    1. Jim Grey Avatar

      Since I wrote this, my mother gave me her original 1963 copy of this record!

    2. Jim Grey Avatar

      Nat King Cole is great! I have one of his Christmas albums as well.

  6. DougD Avatar

    I like the scratches and pops, haven’t heard any of that in a while. My goodness, the doopie doos….

    I’ve been looking for my favourite bluegrass acoustic Christmas CD for weeks. I’ve found the case so far. It’s empty.

    1. Jim Grey Avatar

      It is a rarity these days. I remember when it was the norm.

  7. SilverFox Avatar

    Thanks for this Jim, listening to Johnny now on my last day in the office before Christmas. :)

    1. SilverFox Avatar

      We picked up some random Christmas vinyl over the last year or so and my Fiancee brought some from her home too so we have a reasonable stack. Both of these albums however may need to be added for next year.

      1. Jim Grey Avatar

        Excellent, my nefarious plan is working.

    2. Jim Grey Avatar

      Happy Christmas to you!

  8. Russ Ray Avatar

    Interesting info… I actually grew up listening to the Christmas with Johnny Mathis cassette, and when I was a kid, there was an FM station in Crawfordsville (I think 103.9) that played Christmas music and my dad was able to pick it up on a room-filling stereo that we had in our living room.

    My personal favorites off of that album are the title track and Christmas Is a Feeling In Your Heart. They are definitely whimsical pieces of work. Between the cassette and the , Christmas just never felt like Christmas without Johnny Mathis.

    1. Jim Grey Avatar

      I remember those room-filling stereos!

      I think that’s the thing about the Mathis Christmas music: he could capture whimsy like no other artist.

  9. SilverFox Avatar

    I am now the proud owner of an original vinyl copy of ‘Johnny Mathis, Sounds of Christmas’ :D
    Looking forward to listening to it next Christmas!

    1. Jim Grey Avatar

      Excellent! My nefarious plan is working!

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: